Section 55 of the Income Tax Act: Capital Gains & Cost of Acquistion and Improvement

Understanding tax laws can often feel complicated, but certain sections are crucial for every taxpayer to know, especially when dealing with property or investments. The Section 55 Income Tax Act is one such vital provision. It plays a key role in determining the tax you pay on profits from selling an asset. This section provides the specific rules for calculating the ‘cost of acquisition’ and ‘cost of improvement’, which are fundamental to computing your taxable capital gains tax in India.

Section 55 of Income Tax Act: Quick Info

Here’s a quick summary of how Section 55 impacts capital gains tax by defining cost of acquisition and improvement for various types of assets.

Aspect	Details
Purpose	Defines cost of acquisition and improvement for capital gains calculation
Applies To	Intangible assets, unlisted shares, goodwill, tenancy rights, etc.
Cost of Acquisition	May be treated as 'Nil' if not determinable (especially for intangibles)
Capital Gains Impact	Helps compute accurate taxable gain when selling certain types of assets
Amended In	Finance Act 2023 (relevant for changes to cost computation rules)
Who It Affects	Investors, business owners, and individuals selling intangible assets
Linked Sections	Section 48 (Capital Gains), Section 49 (Acquisition through inheritance)
Tax Benefit	Clarifies computation to avoid excess tax on assets with undefined purchase cost

Key Definitions Under Section 55

To understand Section 55 properly, it is important to be familiar with some basic terms. This section defines these terms to bring uniformity to tax calculations across the country.

• Capital Asset: This refers to any kind of property held by a person, whether it is connected to their business or not. It includes land, buildings, shares, mutual funds, and jewellery.
• Cost of Acquisition (COA): This is the total price you paid to purchase or acquire an asset. It includes the purchase price and any expenses incurred to complete the purchase, such as brokerage fees or legal charges.
• Cost of Improvement (COI): This refers to any capital expenditure you incur to make additions or alterations to an asset, thereby increasing its value. It does not include routine repair and maintenance costs.
• Fair Market Value (FMV): This is the price that an asset would sell for in the open market on a particular date. It is an estimate of what a willing buyer would pay to a willing seller.
• Indexed Cost of Acquisition (ICOA): This is an adjusted cost of acquisition calculated to account for inflation over the years. This benefit is available for long-term capital assets and helps in reducing the taxable gain.

How Section 55 Affects Capital Gains Calculation?

Section 55 directly impacts the calculation of your capital gains.. The basic formula for capital gains is:

Capital Gains = Sale Price - (Cost of Acquisition + Cost of Improvement)

By providing specific rules on how to determine the cost of acquisition and improvement, Section 55 ensures that the profit you are taxed on is fair and accurately reflects the real gain you have made. This is particularly important for capital gain on sale of property, where these costs can be substantial.

Cost of Acquisition as per Section 55

Here’s how the cost is determined for certain intangible and financial assets:

Type of Asset	Rule for Cost of Acquisition (COA)	Example
Goodwill of a business, Trademark, Brand Name, Tenancy Rights	If purchased from a previous owner, the COA is the purchase price. If it is self-generated, the COA is considered to be NIL.	If you start a business and build a brand name from scratch, its acquisition cost is zero. If you sell this brand name, the entire sale amount is your capital gain.
Financial Instruments (e.g., Right Shares)	Section 55 2aa Income Tax Act deals with this. The cost of the right to subscribe to shares (renounced in someone's favour) is NIL. The cost for the person who buys the right is the price paid for the right plus the amount paid to the company.	If a company offers you the right to buy shares and you sell that right to a friend, your cost for that right is zero. Your friend's cost will be what they paid you plus what they paid the company.
Bonus Shares	If allotted before April 1, 2001, the COA is the Fair Market Value on that date. If allotted on or after April 1, 2001, the COA is NIL.	You received 100 bonus shares in 2010. Your cost of acquiring these shares is considered zero. When you sell them, the entire sale price is used to calculate your gain.
Shares received on Demutualisation	As per Section 55(2)(ab), the cost of shares received by a member of a stock exchange under a demutualisation scheme is the cost of their original membership.

These specific rules prevent ambiguity and ensure that the profits from the sale of such assets are taxed correctly.

Cost of Improvement Under Section 55

Just like the cost of acquisition, the cost of improvement is a crucial deduction that reduces your taxable capital gains. Section 55(1)(b) of the Income Tax Act defines what can be considered a cost of improvement.

Key rules for the cost of improvement are:

• Definition: It is any expenditure of a capital nature incurred to make additions or alterations to a capital asset. This means the expense must enhance the asset's value, not just maintain it. For example, adding a new floor to a house is a cost of improvement, while repainting the walls is a maintenance expense.
• Cut-off Date: Any expenditure incurred on improving an asset before April 1, 2001, cannot be claimed as a cost of improvement. Only improvements made on or after this date are considered.
• Nil Cost for Certain Assets: For assets like self-generated goodwill of a business or the right to carry on any business or profession, the cost of improvement is always taken as NIL.

Understanding these rules ensures you claim the correct deductions when calculating your short-term capital gains tax or long-term gains.

Fair Market Value Option – 2001 Rule

A very important provision within Section 55 2b Income Tax Act relates to assets acquired before April 1, 2001. This rule provides significant relief to taxpayers holding old assets.

For any capital asset acquired before April 1, 2001, the taxpayer has a choice. They can consider their cost of acquisition to be either the original price they paid for it or its Fair Market Value (FMV) as on April 1, 2001, whichever is higher.

Scenario	Original Cost of Asset	FMV on April 1, 2001	Cost of Acquisition to be Considered
1. House purchased in 1995	₹5 Lakhs	₹15 Lakhs	₹15 Lakhs (Higher of the two)
2. Land purchased in 1990	₹2 Lakhs	₹1 Lakh	₹2 Lakhs (Higher of the two)

By choosing the higher value as the cost, the taxpayer can increase their cost base, which in turn reduces their taxable capital gain. For land and buildings, a recent amendment specifies that the FMV cannot exceed the stamp duty value of the property as on April 1, 2001.

Judicial Precedents & CBDT Circulars

Over the years, the interpretation of Section 55 of the Income Tax Act has been shaped by various court rulings and clarifications from the Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT). These judgments and circulars have helped resolve ambiguities related to what constitutes a cost of acquisition or improvement in complex cases, such as in family settlements, inheritances, or for specific types of intangible assets, ensuring the law is applied fairly and consistently.

How NoBroker Can Help?

Section 55 of the Income Tax Act is fundamental for tax planning, especially when you are selling a significant asset like a property. Properly determining your cost of acquisition and improvement can significantly reduce your tax liability. For complex cases involving inherited property, intangible assets, or old assets, seeking professional guidance is highly advisable. NoBroker’s legal experts can help you navigate these complexities, ensuring you comply with the law and optimise your tax planning. Always refer to the latest tax updates for current FMV and indexation norms.

Frequently Asked Questions